1) Describe how the introduction captured your interest, or suggest ways to improve:Reviewer’s comment: 2) What is the argumentative thesis statement of the paper (Claim + Reason)? If not evident in the introductory paragraph, suggest ways to improve:Reviewer’s comment: 3) Comment on the researched support given to the argument. Are examples from these texts satisfactory? Which quotes worked best to support thesis?Reviewer’s comment: 4) Describe the effectiveness of how the sources used for support are synthesized by supporting points in the body paragraphs?Reviewer’s comment: 5) What opposing points are presented and how well are they refuted? Can you think of opposition the writer did not consider?:Reviewer’s comment: 6) Describe how well the main points of the paper are summarized in the conclusion, and how the writer reminds readers of position taken on the controversy explored in the essay:Reviewer’s comment:
