When reading a scholarly work, you want to approach it as an analyst, actively peeling it apart instead of working your way page by page. The main things that you need to cover are: topic, structure of the book, author’s thesis, evidence used, and significance in the field. These items should be able to be covered in a 4-6 page dissection, this does not include the references page.
Much of this information can be gleaned by looking at the table of contents, paying careful attention to the introduction and conclusion, and reading reviews of the book. Before making your way through the body chapters, the meat of the book, you should read the introduction and conclusion and think about the topic, structure etc. You will need to read the main chapters to get a sense of the evidence used and the success of the author’s argument but can search for these things more effectively when you already have a sense of the author’s goals. Here is an example of a book dissection from another semester: Use a book review to help understand the importance of work within the field ad to help critique the work.
The dissection should follow this structure: